Interesting hand 9
This time two bidding decisions and one playing decision.
1. What would you open holding 
97542
AQ 
7643
AQ ? Do
you open 1NT or 1 spade?
2. You pick up: void
AK5 AQ109874
Q95 as dealer, so what would you open.
1diamond? 2 diamonds? 4 diamonds? 5 diamonds?
Let’s have your decisions
so that partner can see how you deal with these two tricky hands
3.You are playing hand
2 in 5 diamonds and lose the first two club tricks. There is no opposition bidding.The
diamonds on dummy are 632.You lead a
diamond and RHO plays the 5, do you finesse with the Q or play the Ace and hope
to drop the King?
to help these are the diamonds:
AQ109874 and
on dummy 632
Replies
Suppresing a 5 card spade suit is not my line of bidding so I would open 1
spade.The second hand presents me with no real problem opening , I would open
1 diamond, hope that partner responds. On the play hand I would play to drop
the King of diamonds.
Most interesting.
On hand 1 I would open 1spade (unless I was Andrew Robson) Partner would only
support if he/she had spades, which would perforce be of higher rank than mine,
so unlikely to end up in a spade contract otherwise. The disadvantage on NT
is that , although the AQ doubletons are protected on the initial lead, they
could be set up before the spade suit, and the 4 diamonds are paltry. If partner
has strength elsewhere NT contract would be played and the spade opening bid
would deter a lead in that suit.
On hand 2 I would open 2 diamonds by dint of playing ace responses. One would
know immediately if partner held no aces, and if an ace which one (useful when
holding a void) etc. Also with an outside AK and 7 trumps it is fair to consider
it as having 8 playing tricks.
Hand is very difficult. I have seen arguments in favour of both the finesse
and the drop with 3 missing cards .As I see it, with K and J missing the situation
could be.
KJ5 none
K5 J
J5 K
5 KJ
How can one decide. it depends who has played AK clubs. If both played from
one hand I would place K diamonds with the other. Statistically I'm not sufficiently
conversant with the odds. All things being equal I would go for the drop.
Comment
There is little to choose between opening 1
or 1NT, but I prefer the former. Certainly with three small cards in the suit
it is likely to play much better in the suit than 1NT, as establishing the suit
for no trumps might consume too many entries
Hand 2 certainly qualifies for a 2
opening under the rule of 25, but the suit is rather broken. The problem with
a 1 opening is what do you rebid if
partner responds 1?. That certainly
does not enhance the hand. I suppose 3
serves best.Those who open 2 (either
8 playing tricks in diamonds or in an "undisclosed suit") probably
have an easier ride and if you get any diamond support you can cue bid your
void in diamonds
Hand 3 is simpler. In the absence of any other information
take the finesse.
Wth 8 cards in the suit finesse for K and /or the Q.With
9 cards in the suit , finesse for the K but not the Q ("the saying 8 ever,
9 never")With 10 cards in the suit finesse for
the K, but with 11 cards play for the drop of the K
In this case playing this hand I finessed , held my breath
and it worked